c. 2004 Religion News Service
VATICAN CITY _ European Union leaders, who gathered in Rome Friday (Oct. 29) to sign their new constitution, handed Pope John Paul II a rebuff in his effort to secure an acknowledgment of Christianity in the historic document.
The Roman Catholic pontiff has often voiced concern about Europe’s increasingly secular society. In the signing of a constitution that does not take note of Europe’s religious history, the Vatican sees proof that the EU is distancing itself from Christianity in general and Catholicism in particular.
The drafters of the constitution have made it clear for months that they would ignore the pope’s tireless 21/2-year campaign for explicit Christian recognition in the constitution’s preamble. The pope’s opponents, with France, Belgium and Finland in the forefront, argued that a reference to Christianity would have violated the principle of church-state separation.
Ironically enough, the signing ceremony, held in Rome’s Renaissance city hall, took place under the 17th century bust of a pope, Innocent X (1644-1655), who was deeply involved in the politics of the post-Thirty Years’ War period.
The charter, which still must be ratified by all 25 members of the enlarged EU to take effect, does uphold religious freedom, however. And the EU Parliament, in a conciliatory gesture, appropriated 1.5 million euro ($1.9 million) Thursday to support the church’s World Youth Day celebrations, which are expected to draw hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions, of mainly Catholic young people to Cologne, Germany, next summer.
For John Paul, this was not good enough.
“You don’t cut off the roots from which you have grown,” the pope said with unusual bitterness when forced to acknowledge defeat last June.
Earlier this week came a second blow from the EU.
Opposition within the European Parliament blocked confirmation of an Italian candidate for commissioner of justice and security who was criticized for his conservative views on homosexuality and marriage, which mirror church doctrine.
The candidate, center-right politician and academic Rocco Buttiglione, called homosexuality “a sin,” although not a crime, and upheld marriage as an institution that existed for women to have children and be protected by their husbands.
Compounding the offense to the Vatican, Buttiglione has a warm acquaintance with the pope.
(OPTIONAL TRIM FOLLOWS)
As liberals mounted opposition to Buttiglione’s candidacy, Cardinal Renato Raffaele Martino, the Vatican’s longtime permanent observer at the United Nations who is now president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, exploded. He told a Vatican news conference Oct. 18 that Christians in general and the Catholic Church in particular face “a new holy Inquisition full of money and arrogance.”
“Everything goes, from intimidation to public dishonor, as long as it serves to silence their voices,” he said.
On Thursday (Oct. 28), the eve of the signing ceremony, the pope met at the Vatican with another Italian politician for whom he has affection, retiring EU Commission President Romano Prodi, a leader of Italy’s center-left.
John Paul took the opportunity to make his own feelings about the EU known.
Those feelings are clearly ambivalent. During the Cold War the Polish-born pontiff spoke of his hope for the day when Europe would once more “breathe with both its lungs,” East with West, and the Vatican assured Ukraine only Wednesday that it supports the “return of all the countries of the East to the bosom of the great European family.”
“The Holy See favored the formation of the European Union even before it had a juridical structure and then followed its various stages with active interest,” John Paul said in his welcome to Prodi.
But, the pope said, the Vatican also has felt the duty “to openly express the just expectations of a great number of Christian citizens of Europe.”
“For this reason, the Holy See has reminded everyone how Christianity, in its various expressions, contributed to the formation of a common conscience of the European peoples and gave a great contribution to molding their civilization,” he said.
“Recognized or not in official documents, it is an undeniable fact that no history will be able to forget,” the pope said.
John Paul made a more guarded reference to the Buttiglione controversy, which has forced Prodi’s successor, Jose Manuel Barroso of Portugal, to delay a vote on his own appointment and that of the entire new European Commission. Barroso is under pressure to withdraw Buttiglione’s nomination.
“I express the hope that the difficulties arising in recent days regarding the new commission may find a solution of reciprocal respect in the spirit of harmony between all the requests involved,” he said.
Because of his increasing frailty and the effects that Parkinson’s disease has had on his ability to speak clearly, the 84-year-old pope did not go through the formality of reading the message. The Vatican distributed the official text.
MO RNS END
