Active RNS subscribers and members can view this content at the RNS Archives website.

ROME (RNS) Archbishop Georg Ganswein -- who works with Benedict XVI -- said one year after his resignation on Feb. 11, 2013, the former pope is at peace in his new role.


  1. All the circumstances that surrounded Josef Ratzinger’s career from a conscripted member of Hitler’s youth movement, to priest, to liberal advisor at Vatican II, to evolving conservative theology professor at Tubingen and finally at Regensburg, to bishop of Munich, to his assignment as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and cardinal by John Paul II, with everything set in motion for Ratzinger to be John Paul’s successor, it is very sad that during the long, later stages of that clerical ascendancy, he fell so out of step with the religious thoughts and feelings of the vast majority of Catholics over whom he was eventually set as “divine ruler.”

    Georg Ganswein, “Gorgeous George” of Benedict’s reign, has good reason to defend his promoter. He was expectedly made an immediate archbishop by his mentor in December of 2012, just two months before Benedict’s abdication, when both knew that the resignation was coming. Things are done just as boldly in the Cathoic hierarchy as they are done among the politicians of the United States. Have you noticed the ascendancy of Cardinal Sean O’Malley of Boston paired with the descendency of the loud and bold political animal Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York? To say nothing of the ornately dressed Cardinal Raymond Burke of the curia. Thank you, Francis!

    In the midst of all this plain church politics, it is still sad that Josef Ratzinger-Benedict was, or became, so out of tune with his times. He himself announced at the conclave that elected him–in spite of that election being a pre-arranged deal by John Paul and Ratzinger–the electoral College of Cardinals was plainly stacked for the purpose during the extra long “reign” of John Paul–that he, Ratzinger, was no administrator. True, Ratzinger was no administrator. He was a very old-school theological dictator-professor. He ignored Kristallnacht back home, and he virtually attempted to bring about a church version of it during his time at CDF and as pope.

    Ratzinger was an out-of-place academician. He was also extremely out of place with the corruption of the Vatican curia, the mainline theological thinking of the church, and the refusal of the People of God to be dragged back kicking and screaming to pre-Vatican II.

    Ratzinger-Benedict may have no regrets about having resigned, but the church-at-large has no regrets, either. Georg Ganswein must now serve his master in return for all the ecclesiastical rewards bestowed on him, and he fully deserves his moniker, “Gorgeous George,” but I am sure he is chomping at the bit for a piece of action of his own now that he has been relegated to caretaker of the declining Benedict when he, Ganswein, is so relatively young.

    A good shot of real democracy–absolutely including the “lay people”–would work wonders for this dying church. Nothing else will work. And that includes married priests and women priests. Until that happens, the church is retiring along with its former pope. That is good. The old must be buried before a new phoenix can arise from the ashes.

  2. Methinks, the Archbishop of Gotham sounds often like a noisy gong, a clanging cymbal. Without a papal patron, Dolan will fade, but be used by as grist by the NYC media mill.

    Dolan: “Well, that’s enough about me…what do you think about me?”