(RNS) Emperor Nero didn’t exactly “fiddle while Rome burned” in 64 A.D. Some historians think he made prodigious efforts to alleviate the suffering of his people.

Afterward, however, the emperor did what weak leaders often do: He named a scapegoat. He pointed to the irritating new religious sect known as the “Christians” and said they had caused the fire.

Rather than deal with shoddy infrastructure — in this case, a densely crowded city built of wood — Nero blamed the outliers and had them tortured publicly in the Coliseum.

Something similar is happening today along our southwestern borders and elsewhere in the U.S., where yet another tide of nativism is surging.

The world of work has changed. Factory work has dwindled and robots are arriving. Foreigners are building today’s production sites. Other ways to access the middle class have stopped working. Being white and male no longer guarantees privilege.

As a result, family budgets are tight; self-esteem is challenged. Available jobs pay poorly and increasingly are occupied by women. Meanwhile, successful young techies live large and loud, and top earners adopt a lordly attitude of entitlement and superiority.

In a sense, a way of life is “burning,” just as the great seat of empire once burned. Ideologues who know how to exploit human suffering but have little interest in resolving it have pointed to today’s outliers, dark-skinned immigrants and refugees, and said, “They are to blame.”

They are taking the jobs, the line goes. They are ruining America’s way of life. They are threatening our cultural consensus. If we don’t stop their “invasion,” America will cease to recognize itself.

Like Nero’s scapegoating of Christians, those claims make no rational sense. It isn’t Mexican immigrants who caused sea changes in the American workplace. That was modernity, technology, offshoring of manual work and a shift from making things at high pay to servicing things at low pay.

It wasn’t Hondurans or Guatemalans who sucked the life out of American communities. That was Wal-Mart and a big-box retail economy that abandoned American suppliers and bought overseas, then drove local retailers out of business and abused their own workers with low pay, part-time staffing and few benefits.

Those decisions were made in the executive suite, not in desperate border crossings by frightened Hispanics. Vigilantes patrolling the borders for river-crossers are chasing the wrong enemy. Gun-toting whites shouting hatred at refugee children and blocking their passage to shelters are spewing venom at the wrong target.

Two ironies emerge. First is the long-standing irony of struggling whites blaming the wrong cause of their deprivation and failing to join forces with their logical allies against their actual oppressors.

If they could look beyond race, they would see that this migrant population could help them take back democracy from the supremely rich.

Second is the irony of shouting down refugee children on Saturday and then going to church on Sunday, where the center is a Savior who himself was an oppressed refugee and who later said, “Let the children come to me” and “do to the least of these.”

To justify rejecting refugees by referencing Christian identity shows disregard for what the gospel actually says.

These misguided “patriots” undermine their own future by giving another free pass to the ones actually oppressing them. They wound the nation by violating the very reason we exist as a nation. And they demean faith.

(Tom Ehrich is a writer, church consultant and Episcopal priest based in New York. He is the president of Morning Walk Media and publisher of Fresh Day online magazine. His website is www.morningwalkmedia.com. Follow Tom on Twitter @tomehrich.)



  1. This guys stuff is completely nuts. Every article he has posted is the opposite of sound logic. He could only exist as he does in a time a place like modern america. He couldn’t make it using the best of the thinking available to him in a older and harder time or place.

  2. Illegal immigrant labor is a chief cause for low prices on domestic goods. There is a vested interest to keep the system as draconian as possible in order to keep people in an exploitable illegal status.

    Our legal immigration system is also easily exploited with employment related visas. Unless one is an entertainer, professional athlete or overpaid executive from a European or Japanese company coming over for a few year stretch, the system is always skewed to hire workers at lower than market rates.

    There is no more willfully ignorant group out there than the nativists. They talk a big deal about enforcing laws but almost never know a damn thing about the laws in question. They propose ideas which attack basic civil liberties of all people. Let them talk long enough and it always devolves into some kind of bigoted rants.

  3. Obama bought Latino votes with fake promises of “immigration Reform” and making things easier on illegal immigrants.

    Obama got what HE wanted from the Latinos, but now the immigant Latino children have nowhere to go but DEAD!

    Good job, Mr. Obama. First you betray America, then you betray Latin America too. You are the Slime-In-Chief, by a landslide.

    • Give me a break Doc. Republicans were really going to court the Hispanic vote in 2012 when their party was all but demonizing them at the time? After Arizona had declared “walking while brown” illegal? In 4 years crazed nativitsts had undone all the work GWB did in creating links to that community. Obama only had to be a democrat to court the Hispanic vote.

      As for immigration reform, savvy government officials from both parties have known our immigration system needs to be fixed for decades. It doesn’t really work as intended. Anyone who knows a damn thing about it can tell you that.

      “Obama got what HE wanted from the Latinos, but now the immigant Latino children have nowhere to go but DEAD!”

      Like you give a crap about children after they are born.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available

Comments with many links may be automatically held for moderation.