Active RNS subscribers and members can view this content at the RNS Archives website.

(RNS) The theater’s board decided not to host the festival under its current sponsorship arrangement because of the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict.


  1. There is a difference between criticism of Israel and anti-Zionism. I have been critical of the current Israeli government, myself. The idea that Jews are the only people on the planet who should not have a state where they can control their own destiny is a form of antisemitism. Zionism if the legitimate national liberation movement of the Jewish people.

    • I think the idea thay jews are “a people” is far fetched.

      Are they “a people” based on race? No. There are black jews, sephardic, oriental, etc.

      Are they “a people” based on religon? Perhaps.

      But then why is it not ok for other religons to demand a nation state for their “people”? As in christian.

      Why does the exclusions that apply to israel not apply to other “people”? Why are their cries for more “democracy” from the outside regarding islamic states in the middle east? Why can they just not remain islamic exclusively as israel is jewish exclusively?

  2. The issue was not that it was a ‘Jewish’ film festival, rather that it received funding from the Israeli government. The theatre’s board clearly made this distinction by offering to provide alternative funding to cover the event, and thus ensure that the celebration of Jewish culture, which the event represented, was not jeapordised. Their stance is similar to how the South African government was regarded during apartheid.

    The festival organisers are essentially arguing that a boycott or protest against the government of Israel is akin to to a boycott or protest against Jewish culture. In other words the implication is that the government = the state = the culture and Jews in general. This is of course nonsensical since there are Jewish organisations which are protesting the actions of the Israeli government and who support the BDS movement.

  3. Lies Nat, Christians have never claimed to be an ethnic group or a people. Israel has never been exclusively Jewish. There have always been Muslims and Christians living in Israel. They have complete freedom of religion in Israel. Jews are not asking for anything special. Zionists thought that Jews could be a nation like the French or the Germans are a nation. They thought that would make Jews like everyone else, but that hasn’t happened. Jews are always seen differently than everyone else. They cannot be normal, because no one treats Jews like everyone else. This does not mean that Zionism has failed. It means that a homeland for Jews is needed more than ever.

    Disagreeing with the Israeli government does not means that you support BDS. I don’t think BDS ends the occupation one day sooner. It only helps the Israeli right. I just think that it makes the boycotters feel smug and self-righteous.

  4. I forgot to mention that Jewish Film Festivals almost always have at least one Israeli film. It would be foolish to ignore a major source of Jewish film making, israeli films. That would be enough for BDS supporters to oppose a Jewish Film Festival. The BDS supporters are not just opposing the Israeli government, they are opposed to anything Israeli, including academics and other Israelis who are not connected to the Israeli government.

  5. @ – Lles; Good point “Are they “a people” based on religion? Perhaps.” this is the reason I keep reading and looking for thought snacks. Abraham left UR, Moses gathered those that remained along with a “mixed multitude” they all intermarried, with Canaanites, then with Babylonians, Medes, Persians, Greeks, Romans as well, and here we are today!

  1. Comment marked as low quality by the editors. Show comment
  2. Comment marked as low quality by the editors. Show comment
  3. Comment marked as low quality by the editors. Show comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available

Comments with many links may be automatically held for moderation.