VATICAN CITY (RNS) The head of the Vatican department that oversees men’s and women’s religious orders says he was left in the dark about the Vatican investigation that led to the makeover of the largest umbrella group for American nuns.

Cardinal Joao Braz de Aviz

In a story first reported by National Catholic Reporter, Brazilian Cardinal Joao Braz de Aviz, head of the Vatican’s Congregation for religious orders, said on Sunday (May 5) that the tensions sparked by the Vatican crackdown of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious caused him “much pain.” Photo courtesy Cristina Gallo/Agência Senado via Wikimedia Commons (

This image is available for Web publication. For questions, contact Sally Morrow.

In a story first reported by National Catholic Reporter, Brazilian Cardinal Joao Braz de Aviz, head of the Vatican’s Congregation for religious orders, said on Sunday (May 5) that the tensions sparked by the Vatican crackdown of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious caused him “much pain.”

Braz de Aviz’ remarks reflect the turf battles encumbering the Vatican, as Pope Francis sets about to reform the Roman Curia, or central bureaucracy, and add a new layer of intrigue to one of the major stories involving the American church in recent years.

In April 2012, the Vatican issued a “doctrinal assessment” that criticized the LCWR for not speaking out strongly enough against gay marriage, abortion and women’s ordination.

The Vatican also chided the organization for “serious doctrinal problems” among many LCWR members, and said LCWR conferences suffered from “a prevalence of certain radical feminist themes incompatible with the Catholic faith.”

Seattle Archbishop J. Peter Sartain was appointed to overhaul the group’s practices and perceived theological ambiguities.

While the choice to discipline U.S. sisters became one of the defining acts of Benedict XVI’s pontificate, Francis last month “reaffirmed the findings” of the Vatican investigation and the “program of reform” for LCWR, which represents the majority of America’s 57,000 nuns.

Speaking at the meeting of the International Union of Women Superiors, Braz de Aviz said the decision to issue the critical report on U.S. sisters was taken without even informing or consulting his office.

When the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican’s doctrinal watchdog, informed him of its findings, Braz de Aviz said, the investigation was already completed.

At a subsequent meeting with CDF leaders, Braz de Aviz complained about the lack of information-sharing between Vatican departments, according to the NCR report.

“We will obey what the Holy Father wants and what will be decided through you … But we must say that this material which should be discussed together has not been discussed together,” Braz de Aviz told the then-CDF chief, American Cardinal William Levada.

In an official interview given during the event, the cardinal said that “dialogue” between LCWR and the Vatican is “possible,” noting that “it isn’t just a matter of ‘we are right, they are wrong,’” he said.

Braz de Aviz also expressed his appreciation for the Rome gathering’s decision to discuss issues of authority within the Catholic Church. “It is a problem I feel a lot too, not in order to weaken authority but to put (authority) under a higher light,” he said.

According to Vatican Radio, the cardinal spoke of the “need for a wide-ranging review of structures of power within the Catholic Church.”

Francis is expected to briefly meet with a group of women superiors, including LCWR’s president Sister Florence Deacon, on Wednesday (May 7).

During his Sunday homily at the conference, Braz de Aviz also described the process that led to the appointment of his new deputy, José Rodríguez Carballo, in what is Francis’ only appointment within the Roman Curia so far.

The No. 2 position had been left vacant after Benedict transferred Archbishop Joseph Tobin to Indianapolis last October.

Francis asked Braz de Aviz to present him with a list of three names, and only asked who was Braz de Aviz’ preferred choice. The cardinal then named Carballo as his favorite candidate, and the pope simply accepted his suggestion.

“It’s a very simple way of doing things … it doesn’t overcomplicate things,” Braz de Aviz said.


  1. The Roman Catholic church has an enormous mess on its hands and frankly the role of nuns is not one of them. They are not running for office among New Englanders and it is not up for a vote. They have a major problem with policy and procedure (such as celibacy), recruitment, finance, doctrine (almost non-Christian), ritual (borders on idolatry), ex cathedra, canons, creed, interdenominational respect (ecumenism) .. it is a true Gordian knot. You could start any place and it is a mess. The bureaucracy of Cardinals and Bishops are even more entrenched than the U.S. military officer corps. (to a man with a hammer everything is a nail). It think the Roman Catholic church and others like it will become extinct because they do not know how to become Christian.

  2. I’ll take the word of Cardinal Braz de Aviz any day before I accept any more deceitful words or actions from anyone related the the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Under John Paul and Benedict, it has been no different than in its previous existence as the Office of the (so-called) Holy Inquisition.

    If Francis wants to start curing the awful corruption in the curia, besides the Vatican Bank, he should close down the CDF. We do not need anyone, prelates or anyone else, dictating doctrines to us. There is so much wrong with the Vatican that it too should be closed down as a church headquarters and turned into a library and a museum of what church should never become.

    Catholic Church history is proof that a “universal church” cannot succeed. It requires evil to attempt it. When any functions become so big they guarantee failure, whether they be big corporations, banks, Wall St. investment companies, or churches, they should be allowed to fail, to cease, to die. They die of their own diseased doings, anyway. We should not allow them to continue and cause destruction to others.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments with many links may be automatically held for moderation.